A non-compete agreement is a clause stating an employee will refrain from activity that competes with their current employer. The employee usually signs this contract upon hiring, and it takes effect when they no longer work for that employer. Employers must write non-compete clauses in specific ways to be considered valid. Many courts do not uphold or enforce overly restrictive non-compete agreements.
Non-compete agreements limit an employee’s actions and possible future employment after leaving a company. Types of activities include:
Typically, high-level employees, such as directors, executives, owners, or others with specialized knowledge, will sign a non-compete agreement.
Employers propose a non-compete agreement to protect their relationship with customers and confidential business information. While it limits what an employee can do during and after working for the company, it must do so within reason. Otherwise, courts might not enforce the agreement.
To be valid, non-compete agreements must have reasonable definitions for time, region, and competitive work or behavior.
The non-compete agreement must also consider public interest. It cannot prohibit an employee from working at a company against public interest. For instance, if a nurse ends employment at one hospital, the non-compete agreement cannot deny the nurse from working at a nearby hospital with a nursing shortage. Doing so would be in opposition to public interest.
Non-compete agreements can be complex. Here are some answers to frequently asked questions.
First, identify if it is enforceable. If the provisions are too broad, place undue hardship on the employee, or conflict with public interest, the contract may not be valid.
Next, consider if the contract offered sufficient consideration. Consideration means the employee was given something valuable in exchange for the non-compete agreement. For example, an employer may grant employment to an individual upon signing the non-compete agreement. This is sufficient consideration because the job itself is valuable. But if an employee signed a non-compete agreement after being hired and did not receive anything valuable in return, it may not be enforceable.
If, after reviewing the contract and it appears to be valid, consider discussing with the employer to release the non-compete agreement. If the employee and employer agree to the release, putting it in writing will protect both parties.
It depends. By definition, independent contractors are not employees, therefore they are not under the same obligations as employees. They often work for several companies within their field. Consequently, companies cannot limit them from future work with competing businesses. However, a court may enforce a non-compete agreement if a contractor engages in activity that a court finds directly competing with the current company. Starting a competing business while working for a company and using their trade secrets may violate the non-compete agreement.
Non-competes are enforced in different ways. Many state laws have evolved over the years, and courts have restricted the enforceability of non-compete agreements. California and Oregon, for example, have passed statutes that narrowly limit the circumstances under which a non-compete agreement can be enforced. Some states, such as Virginia, have banned non-compete agreements for low-wage workers.
However, courts can still enforce a non-compete agreement under the right circumstances. Therefore, it is wise to understand a company’s non-compete clause before taking action that may go against the agreement.